Skip to main content

American Dad "Fantasy Baseball" Review

This is actually one of the first times I can remember American Dad doing a timely episode, with baseball season having just started a few weeks ago. Apart from the occasional case of inconsistent writing, this was a very solid start to the latest season of this show.




"Fantasy Baseball" starts with a premise that may very well put you to sleep, as Stan gets upset at Steve for not having any interest in something he considers legitimate. It's the type of storyline we've seen approximately a hundred million times on this show, and is so played out I don't think it legally qualifies as content anymore. But I will give the writers credit for introducing a more interesting conflict between the traditional aspects of the sport and the need to stay relevant the age we live in. It's truthful enough to say that baseball has largely lost the common touch, especially with teenagers and young adults, and the division grows more and more with each passing day. The show didn't even get into the racial divide of baseball fans, though that is probably for the best. Anyway, somehow this story pivots to Steve becoming an umpire through accidentally killing his predecessor, which is very American Dad. Now that Steve is actually involved in the game, he has the chance to earn Stan's respect, but instead introduces a radical shift, turning baseball into Dungeons & Dragons instead. The D&D/baseball hybrid is actually quite wonderful, both in real life and in universe, and Steve begins to bring audiences of all ages back to the sport.


For as much fun there is to be had in Steve just taking over baseball, it also completely turns Stan away, which Steve doesn't seem to care about, for some reason. Steve only got involved with all of this to make his father proud, and then he just goes wild with power. I suppose you're just meant to go with it, but I would've appreciated some sort of explanation. I have to give a shout-out to Steve's re-imagined version of baseball, complete with lions, horses and moats. Being completely serious, the MLB could introduce this tomorrow, and I think it might work. It all looks really fun, though the Player's Union might have some issues. The resolution to the conflict between Stan and Steve isn't much, as they bond over the lesser hybrid between their two favorite pastimes. It's a lackluster end to a fun storyline, but doesn't completely take any from the enjoyment.


Pardon the pun, but the B-plot this week knocks it out of the park, as Roger tries to replace Francine's favorite soap opera. The escalating gags, from trying to sabotage Hayley and Jeff's marriage to semen trucks and Roger's eventual arrest is the type of stuff American Dad is incredible at, and nothing disappoints. Perhaps the best part of this craziness was Francine's meta commentary on Klaus, and if you've watched this show for some time, you were probably nodding your head to all of it.


8/10


The main story of "Fantasy Baseball" which is great name by the way, mostly avoid the cliches and predictable nature of most Stan-Steve conflicts. The fact that it reverts to the tried and true by the end is underwhelming, but I don't know how else all of this could really be resolved. Now if you'll excuse me, it's time for the seventh inning stretch, which is performed tonight by my dog..............and dubstep.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

American Dad "Twinanigans" Review

It's been a while since the last Steve and Roger episode, and this week reminded me why that's such a classic American Dad pairing. This is a genuinely fun episode, filled with some great one liners and even a great callback to the show's past. "Twinanigans" centers around the heretofore unmentioned acting careers of Roger and Steve, who twinned it up as the Smith Brothers. I'm not going to question whether this backstory actually makes sense to the overall timeline; no one watches American Dad for continuity. Steve had to give up acting to attend kindergarten, and wants to give Roger a second chance at greatness. The two head to auditions, where Steve impresses and Roger blows it. It's here the episode kinda misfires, as it's never made abundantly clear why Roger struggles so much at acting. Is he just trying too hard, does he have some form of stage fright, does he not even know what acting is? This part of the story is just never explained, w...

Curious Crab

One Monday night my mom looked into my crabitat and found that a crab had climbed into one of my fake trees. It was in the top branch. I looked in later, and found that the crab had fallen out of the tree. I hope he is okay. What a day!

The Route of Life

dedicated to my hermits, who changed my life Ch 1 My Hermit crabs Hermit crabs are sometimes hard to take care of. Especially when you never had a hermit. Last Sunday afternoon I got 2 Hermit crabs. Their names are Crabbe and Goyle. I have talked with many sales people. The first Petco we went to (where we got the hermits and their things) seemed to have no idea on the subject. So we ended up going to Dolphin Pet Village. They were more experience at the subject. Now we have some of the things we will need. Last week, I went to a second Petco. There we got a cuttlebone, which is the bone of a fish. Now they look happy. Have a good day Hermit Crabs! Ch 2 Curious Crab The week before last week, my mom looked into my crabitat and found that one of my crabs had climbed one of my fake trees. It was on the top branch. Later, when I was changing to get ready for bed, the crab fell out of his branch. I hope he is okay. He’s definitely starting to look okay. How funny do you think that story is...